CCS Outlook Positive: S&P

Standard & Poor’s has announced:

  • •The combined operating performance of CFSL’s operating entities, CGIC and CLIC, has improved.
  • •We view the capital adequacy for the consolidated Co-operators group as
    very strong.
  • •We are affirming the financial strength and issuer credit ratings on CGIC and CLIC and the counterparty credit rating on CFSL.
  • •We revised the outlook on all these ratings to positive from stable.

… that it affirmed its ‘BBB+’ long-term financial strength and issuer credit ratings on the operating companies of the Co-operators Group, Co-operators General Insurance Co. (CGIC) and Co-operators Life Insurance Co. (CLIC). We also affirmed our ‘BBB-‘ long-term counterparty credit rating on their immediate holding company Co-operators Financial Services Ltd. (CFSL). We revised the outlooks on all ratings to positive from stable.

“The positive outlooks reflect our view that the continued and improved capital strength at the consolidated Co-operators group is very strong,” said Standard & Poor’s credit analyst Jieqiu Fan. The significantly improved operating performance at CGIC in the past two years partially benefited from the Ontario Auto Reform that capped escalating accident benefit claims, and was offset somewhat by the weakening operating performance at CLIC. CGIC had underwriting losses in 2008-2010 driven by many claims from the Ontario auto sector. In 2011 CGIC generated underwriting profits, and continued to do so in the first six months of 2012.

The ratings are also based on the company’s strong competitive position as the fifth-largest property/casualty insurance company in Canada and its well-established multichannel distribution. Offsetting these strengths are its concentration in the highly regulated Ontario auto sector and expense ratios higher than peers’.

We expect CLIC’s operating performance to be marginal in 2012, but improve in 2013 to an after-tax return on equity of 4%-5%. We expect CFSL’s debt plus preferred-to-total capital ratio to remain less than 35% and its EBIT fixed-charge coverage to be near or more than 3.5x. In the next 12 months, if the company meets these expectations and we believe this performance level is sustainable, we could raise the ratings by one notch.
Alternatively, we could lower the ratings if the company significantly underperforms (five or more combined ratio points) the Canadian personal lines industry or experiences significant deterioration in its capital strength, reflecting a low ‘A’ level of consolidated capital adequacy.

Co-operators General Insurance Co. (referred to as CGIC in the press release) is the proud issuer of CCS.PR.C and CCS.PR.D. Both are tracked by HIMIPref™; both are relegated to the Scraps index on credit concerns.

S&P rates the preferreds at P-2(low). The company was upgraded to Pfd-3(high) by DBRS in July.

One Response to “CCS Outlook Positive: S&P”

  1. […] This follows the positive outlook announced in October 2012. […]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.