Archive for August, 2008

macroblog Returns!

Tuesday, August 12th, 2008

From Econbrowser comes the great news of macroblog’s return after having been moribund for quite some time.

As Dave Altig explains:

I originally launched macroblog in 2004 as an independent blog, but it will now be run through the Atlanta Fed on our Web site. Macroblog will feature commentary by me as well as other members of the Bank’s research department.

macroblog has been added to the blogroll.

The Evolution of Bankers' Acceptances in Canada

Tuesday, August 12th, 2008

One of my source documents for my research on the seniority of Bankers’ Acceptances was an article from the BoC Review of October 1981, by Daryl Merrett.

This article is not available on the Bank of Canada website, so the staff first very kindly faxed me a copy and now has authorized me to make my electronic version of the fax available here.

These are TIF files of not particularly wonderful quality; but those who are interested in the topic will pay more attention to the content than to the form.

August 11, 2008

Monday, August 11th, 2008

Today’s top news is that inflation is no longer a problem:

Schroder Investment Management’s David Scammell is so convinced inflation has crested that the bond fund manager this quarter has sold securities designed to protect from rising consumer prices.

Scammell is no lonely voice. A survey out today of 25 bond fund managers controlling $1.41 trillion of assets by Jersey City, New Jersey-based Ried, Thunberg & Co. found that 79 percent expect inflation “to moderate late this year into 2009.”

And certainly the market expectations computed by the Cleveland Fed are in a downturn. Isn’t it exciting? I wonder how the world will end next week!

Somebody made a massive bet against Bear Stearns just before its collapse, which is leading to mutterings that the firm’s collapse was a confidence game. This was last discussed on July 17. The Internuts’ position to date has been that BSC was a stupid firm, leveraged up to the eyeballs with junk and having a negative net worth. It will be most interesting to see if they switch to the “evil hedge fund rumour-monger” meme. As for me … sudden losses of confidence happen. Bear Stearns was an extreme example; they shouldn’t have gone under, but management shouldn’t have made them vulnerable either.

Predictions, of course, have a very poor track record. But there’s one prediction I hope comes true … the bond vigilantes were FUN:

The bond vigilantes who’ve been missing in action under George W. Bush may be preparing for a return engagement once Barack Obama or John McCain takes office next year.

“Though times are different and a lot of the government spending is necessary, we’re going to see rates rise in a saw- tooth pattern over the next few years,” says E. Craig Coats Jr., the head of Salomon Brothers’ government securities desk when it was the world’s biggest bond trader. Coats considers himself one of the original vigilantes, the bearish traders who drove up long-term interest rates, persuading Clinton to place deficit-reduction above fulfilling his spending promises.

That course-reversal prompted Clinton political adviser James Carville to observe at the time: “I used to think that if there was reincarnation, I wanted to come back as the president or the pope or as a .400 baseball hitter. But now I would like to come back as the bond market. You can intimidate everybody.”

Another good strong day in the markets, with volume picking up slightly.

Note that these indices are experimental; the absolute and relative daily values are expected to change in the final version. In this version, index values are based at 1,000.0 on 2006-6-30
Index Mean Current Yield (at bid) Mean YTW Mean Average Trading Value Mean Mod Dur (YTW) Issues Day’s Perf. Index Value
Ratchet N/A N/A N/A N/A 0 N/A N/A
Fixed-Floater 4.64% 4.37% 58,179 16.44 7 +0.2048% 1,101.0
Floater 4.07% 4.11% 52,180 17.16 3 +0.6591% 906.2
Op. Retract 4.99% 4.39% 120,598 2.87 17 -0.2857% 1,043.5
Split-Share 5.35% 5.98% 57,726 4.44 14 -0.0408% 1,035.4
Interest Bearing 6.23% 6.65% 48,596 5.27 2 +0.7212% 1,123.7
Perpetual-Premium 6.19% 6.16% 70,571 2.26 1 +0.0396% 988.1
Perpetual-Discount 6.15% 6.20% 204,174 13.61 67 +0.5353% 864.2
Major Price Changes
Issue Index Change Notes
BAM.PR.I OpRet -4.6102% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 7.76% based on a bid of 22.76 and a softMaturity 2013-12-30 at 25.00. Compare with BAM.PR.H (6.49% to 2012-3-30), BAM.PR.J (6.18% to 2018-3-30) and BAM.PR.O (7.17% to 2013-6-30).
BNA.PR.B SplitShare -2.7559% Asset coverage of 3.3+:1 as of July 31, according to the company. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 9.03% based on a bid of 19.76 and a hardMaturity 2016-3-25 at 25.00. Compare with BNA.PR.A (5.84% to 2010-9-30) and BNA.PR.C (9.25% to 2019-1-10).
POW.PR.D PerpetualDiscount -2.4590% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.26% based on a bid of 20.25 and a limitMaturity.
SLF.PR.B PerpetualDiscount -1.2435% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.40% based on a bid of 19.06 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.I PerpetualDiscount +1.0644% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.58% based on a bid of 18.04 and a limitMaturity.
HSB.PR.D PerpetualDiscount +1.1106% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.34% based on a bid of 20.03 and a limitMaturity.
POW.PR.C PerpetualDiscount +1.1154% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.22% based on a bid of 23.57 and a limitMaturity.
PWF.PR.L PerpetualDiscount +1.1319% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.27% based on a bid of 20.55 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.H PerpetualDiscount +1.3400% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.69% based on a bid of 18.15 and a limitMaturity.
BSD.PR.A InterestBearing +1.3699% Asset coverage of 1.6+:1 as of August 8, according to Brookfield Funds. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.96% based on a bid of 9.62 and a hardMaturity 2015-3-31 at 10.00.
BNS.PR.J PerpetualDiscount +1.3772% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.77% based on a bid of 22.82 and a limitMaturity.
BMO.PR.L PerpetualDiscount +1.4370% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.06% based on a bid of 24.00 and a limitMaturity.
HSB.PR.C PerpetualDiscount +1.4881% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.33% based on a bid of 20.46 and a limitMaturity.
GWO.PR.F PerpetualDiscount +1.5847% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.98% based on a bid of 25.00 and a limitMaturity.
BNS.PR.L PerpetualDiscount +1.6026% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.97% based on a bid of 19.02 and a limitMaturity.
RY.PR.W PerpetualDiscount +1.6941% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.03% based on a bid of 20.41 and a limitMaturity.
TCA.PR.Y PerpetualDiscount +1.7125% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.80% based on a bid of 48.11 and a limitMaturity.
BNS.PR.M PerpetualDiscount +1.7657% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.97% based on a bid of 19.02 and a limitMaturity.
SLF.PR.E PerpetualDiscount +1.8172% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.18% based on a bid of 18.49 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.J PerpetualDiscount +2.0882% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.46% based on a bid of 17.60 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.P PerpetualDiscount +3.0288% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.70% based on a bid of 20.75 and a limitMaturity.
Volume Highlights
Issue Index Volume Notes
NA.PR.L PerpetualDiscount 181,265 Nesbitt crossed 175,000 at 18.50. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.51% based on a bid of 18.75 and a limitMaturity.
BNS.PR.L PerpetualDiscount 112,595 National crossed 100,000 at 19.00. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.97% based on a bid of 19.02 and a limitMaturity.
POW.PR.D PerpetualDiscount 80,258 CIBC crossed 73,900 at 20.40. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.26% based on a bid of 20.23 and a limitMaturity.
TD.PR.O PerpetualDiscount 65,084 National crossed 60,000 at 20.95. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.84% based on a bid of 20.85 and a limitMaturity.
SLF.PR.B PerpetualDiscount 55,504 CIBC crossed 50,000 at 19.32. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.40% based on a bid of 19.06 and a limitMaturity.

There were twenty-two other index-included $25-pv-equivalent issues trading over 10,000 shares today.

PerpetualDiscount Duration Calculation

Monday, August 11th, 2008

Very simple.

Given that the yield is “r” per period and that the first payment is received exactly one period hence:

Macaulay Duration = (1+r) / r

Modified Duration = 1 / r

And here’s the proof (TIF file).

Note that, strictly speaking, these are the durations of a perpetual annuity; the assumption of perpetuity gets shakier as redemption becomes more likely.

PFD.PR.A Holders: Show Us the Money!

Monday, August 11th, 2008

JovFunds Management Inc. has announced:

at the special meeting of the preferred shareholders of Charterhouse held today, preferred shareholders voted:

a. Against a proposed resolution to approve an amendment of the articles of incorporation of Charterhouse to permit Charterhouse to redeem all outstanding preferred shares on a merger of Charterhouse into the Fairway Diversified Income and Growth Trust; and

b. For a proposed resolution to approve an amendment to the articles of incorporation of Charterhouse to permit the Corporation to redeem all outstanding preferred shares prior the scheduled redemption date. [sic]

The meeting was previously discussed on PrefBlog.

August, 2008, PrefLetter Released!

Monday, August 11th, 2008

The August, 2008, edition of PrefLetter has been released and is now available for purchase as the “Previous edition”.

Until further notice, the “Previous Edition” will refer to the August, 2008, issue, while the “Next Edition” will be the September, 2008, issue, scheduled to be prepared as of the close September 12 and eMailed to subscribers prior to market-opening on September 15.

PrefLetter is intended for long term investors seeking issues to buy-and-hold. At least one recommendation from each of the major preferred share sectors is included and discussed.

Note: PrefLetter, being delivered to clients as a large attachment by eMail, sometimes runs afoul of spam filters. If you have not received your copy within fifteen minutes of a release notice such as this one, please double check your (company’s) spam filtering policy and your spam repository. If it’s not there, contact me and I’ll get you your copy … somehow!

Errata, 2008-8-13: Typographical errors on page 2 have been found. The price for BNA.PR.C is 17.20-99; the price for BCE.PR.Z is 24.00-25.

August 8, 2008

Friday, August 8th, 2008

Another common equity dividend cut that leaves the preferreds unscathed! This sort of stuff does my heart good!

Fannie Mae, the largest U.S. mortgage- finance company, cut its dividend 86 percent after posting a loss that was more than three times analysts’ estimates and said the worst housing slump since the Great Depression is deepening.

Mudd has raised $14.4 billion since late last year and reduced the dividend from 50 cents since December, though still failed to quell concerns that the company is short of capital. As worries escalated, he dispatched executives to Asia to calm investors. Fannie’s core capital was $47 billion at the end of the quarter, up from $42.7 billion in March, after the company sold $7.4 billion of preferred stock.

The fact that they were able to finance themselves with preferreds underlines the importance to operating companies of maintaining the dividends … Fannie Mae issued $2-billion at 8.25%, $2.25-billion at 8.75% + mandatory conversion and $7-billion at LIBOR+423 last December. The convertable issue, of course, cannot be considered a fixed income security … but the extra security of the dividend until conversion is quite valuable!

The UK Financial Services Authority has concluded its investigation into the HBOS share collapse. Assiduous Readers will remember that the HBOS rights issue flopped. Not suprisingly:

Despite the likelihood that the rumours contributed to the fall in the share price, the FSA has not uncovered evidence that they were spread as part of a concerted attempt by individuals to profit by manipulating the share price.

Of interest is:

The effect of algorithmic trading strategies, which amplified the impact of the initial downward trend in the HBOS share price.

My expectation would have been that algorithmic trading strategies would cushion the downward trend, rather than amplifying it, as swaps between banks became more attractive. Certainly, “algorithmic” doesn’t mean anything in itself, but I would be most interested in learning the details of this automated positive feedback loop … and I bet the FSA is puzzling over this type of trading even now!

Well, a week-odd in to August and things are looking a little better! PerpetualDiscounts are up every day month-to-date, totalling 1.38%. They have had only one down-day (July 28) since the trough on July 16 and are now up 6.62% since trough-date. Average dividend yield is now 6.23%, equivalent to 8.72% interest for taxable holders with a 1.4x equivalency factor; long corporates now yield about 6.15% so the PTIE spread is 257bp … still above the previous ten-year high of 250bp.

Note that these indices are experimental; the absolute and relative daily values are expected to change in the final version. In this version, index values are based at 1,000.0 on 2006-6-30
Index Mean Current Yield (at bid) Mean YTW Mean Average Trading Value Mean Mod Dur (YTW) Issues Day’s Perf. Index Value
Ratchet N/A N/A N/A N/A 0 N/A N/A
Fixed-Floater 4.65% 4.37% 58,468 16.44 7 +0.0879% 1,098.8
Floater 4.10% 4.13% 52,120 17.11 3 0.5182% 900.2
Op. Retract 4.97% 4.23% 121,433 2.83 17 +0.1966% 1,046.5
Split-Share 5.35% 6.00% 57,927 4.46 14 +0.2051% 1,035.8
Interest Bearing 6.28% 6.78% 50,634 5.27 2 -0.3571% 1,115.7
Perpetual-Premium 6.19% 6.15% 71,049 2.27 1 -0.0396% 987.7
Perpetual-Discount 6.18% 6.23% 203,557 13.58 67 +0.2989% 859.6
Major Price Changes
Issue Index Change Notes
CM.PR.P PerpetualDiscount -2.3278% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.90% based on a bid of 20.14 and a limitMaturity.
BNS.PR.K PerpetualDiscount +1.1429% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.70% based on a bid of 21.24 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.D PerpetualDiscount +1.1899% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.83% based on a bid of 21.26 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.H PerpetualDiscount +1.3582% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.77% based on a bid of 17.91 and a limitMaturity.
PWF.PR.E PerpetualDiscount +1.4014% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.16% based on a bid of 22.43 and a limitMaturity.
SLF.PR.A PerpetualDiscount +1.4256% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.28% based on a bid of 19.21 and a limitMaturity.
POW.PR.D PerpetualDiscount +1.4677% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.10% based on a bid of 20.74 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.I PerpetualDiscount +1.5936% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.65% based on a bid of 17.85 and a limitMaturity.
RY.PR.W PerpetualDiscount +1.6203% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.13% based on a bid of 20.07 and a limitMaturity.
BAM.PR.B Floater +1.6316%  
CM.PR.J PerpetualDiscount +1.7109% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.59% based on a bid of 17.24 and a limitMaturity.
ELF.PR.F PerpetualDiscount +1.8182% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.85% based on a bid of 19.60 and a limitMaturity.
MFC.PR.C PerpetualDiscount +1.9191% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.82% based on a bid of 19.65 and a limitMaturity.
WFS.PR.A SplitShare +2.2976% Asset coverage of 1.6+:1 as of July 31, according to Mulvihill. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 8.10% based on a bid of 9.35 and a hardMaturity 2011-6-30 at 10.00.
BAM.PR.J OpRet +2.4765% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.07% based on a bid of 24.00 and a softMaturity 2018-3-30 at 25.00. Compare with BAM.PR.H (6.49% to 2012-3-30), BAM.PR.I (6.70% to 2013-12-30) and BAM.PR.O (7.21% to 2013-6-30).
POW.PR.A PerpetualDiscount +2.5101% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.18% based on a bid of 22.87 and a limitMaturity.
CU.PR.A PerpetualDiscount +2.9399% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.92% based on a bid of 24.51 and a limitMaturity.
Volume Highlights
Issue Index Volume Notes
CM.PR.G PerpetualDiscount 428,195 Nesbitt crossed 400,000 at 20.00, then another 17,500 at the same price. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.78% based on a bid of 20.12 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.I PerpetualDiscount 98,660 CIBC crossed 91,500 at 17.86. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.65% based on a bid of 17.85 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.J PerpetualDiscount 88,839 CIBC crossed 81,500 at 17.26. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.59% based on a bid of 17.24 and a limitMaturity.
RY.PR.K OpRet 60,781 Nesbitt crossed 25,000 at 25.00, then CIBC crossed 27,100 at the same price. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 4.00% based on a bid of 24.97 and optionCertainty 2008-9-7 at 25.00. Has been called for redemption August 22 at 25.00.
RY.PR.H PerpetualDiscount 51,480 Nesbitt bought 10,000 from CIBC at 24.34, CIBC crossed 10,200 at 24.30, Nesbitt bought another 11,800 from CIBC at 24.34, then CIBC crossed another 16,300 at 24.30. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.84% based on a bid of 24.26 and a limitMaturity.

There were seventeen other index-included $25-pv-equivalent issues trading over 10,000 shares today.

Update: Assiduous Reader prefwatcher takes me to task in the comments for not hating the Fannie Mae preferreds and suggests I look at the charts … so here’s the common vs. FNMPRG:

Clearly, not pretty for the preferreds – but, my point was, even less pretty for the common.

My glee at seeing common dividends cut while preferreds continue rolling along is, perhaps, a little exagerated … but there are so many commentators who take the view that preferred dividends are easy to cut I take great pleasure in pointing out contrary evidence. Fannie’s preferred stock is rated A1 Review-Negative by Moody’s, by the way. This note has also attracted attention at FWR.

August PrefLetter Now in Preparation

Friday, August 8th, 2008

The markets have closed and the August edition of PrefLetter is now being prepared.

PrefLetter is the monthly newsletter recommending individual issues of preferred shares to subscribers. There is at least one recommendation from every major type of preferred share; the recommendations are taylored for “buy-and-hold” investors.

The August issue will be eMailed to clients and available for single-issue purchase with immediate delivery prior to the opening bell on Monday. I will write another post on the weekend advising when the new issue has been uploaded to the server … so watch this space carefully if you intend to order “Next Issue” or “Previous Issue”!

August 7, 2008

Thursday, August 7th, 2008

Menzie Chinn of Econbrowser passes along a very gloomy paper on the interaction of recessions, credit contractions, housing price declines and stock market declines:

In particular, we show that recessions associated with credit crunches and house price busts are deeper and last longer than other recessions are.

Citigroup has agreed to a plan to bail-out holders of Auction Rate Securities:

Cuomo accused Citigroup of fraud in an Aug. 1 letter, claiming the firm should have told clients the auction-rate market survived between August 2007 and February 2008 only because of bidding from the bank. The letter demanded Citigroup buy back investors’ holdings in the “immediate future,” reimburse their damages and pay a “significant” fine.

Total craziness. If the politicians and the bureaucrats really think they’re helping the capital markets in the long-term with this sort of nonsense, their successors will have another think coming. All that is accomplished by this sort of thing is the creation of an aversion for anything but the plainest of vanilla offerings from the big investment banks. If any retail-scum investor actually wishes to buy things like this in the future – too bad! It will be too risky for the bank to sell it to you.

Note that these indices are experimental; the absolute and relative daily values are expected to change in the final version. In this version, index values are based at 1,000.0 on 2006-6-30
Index Mean Current Yield (at bid) Mean YTW Mean Average Trading Value Mean Mod Dur (YTW) Issues Day’s Perf. Index Value
Ratchet N/A N/A N/A N/A 0 N/A N/A
Fixed-Floater 4.65% 4.37% 58,346 16.45 7 +0.4065% 1,097.8
Floater 4.12% 4.15% 53,960 17.07 3 0.0000% 895.6
Op. Retract 4.98% 4.18% 121,836 2.77 17 +0.1618% 1,044.4
Split-Share 5.36% 6.06% 58,123 4.46 14 -0.0842% 1,033.7
Interest Bearing 6.25% 6.70% 49,427 5.27 2 +0.4100% 1,119.7
Perpetual-Premium 6.19% 6.13% 68,898 2.27 1 +0.0396% 988.1
Perpetual-Discount 6.20% 6.25% 205,166 13.56 67 +0.3491% 857.0
Major Price Changes
Issue Index Change Notes
NA.PR.L PerpetualDiscount -1.1640% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.53% based on a bid of 18.68 and a limitMaturity.
FFN.PR.A SplitShare -1.1134% Asset coverage of 1.8+:1 as of July 31 according to the company. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.74% based on a bid of 9.77 and a hardMaturity 2014-12-1 at 10.00.
GWO.PR.H PerpetualDiscount +1.0000% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.09% based on a bid of 20.20 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.J PerpetualDiscount +1.0733% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.71% based on a bid of 16.95 and a limitMaturity.
BCE.PR.G FixFloat +1.1642%  
GWO.PR.I PerpetualDiscount +1.2221% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.99% based on a bid of 19.05 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.P PerpetualDiscount +1.2270% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.74% based on a bid of 20.62 and a limitMaturity.
BAM.PR.J OpRet +1.2976% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.41% based on a bid of 23.42 and a softMaturity 2018-3-30 at 25.00. Compare with BAM.PR.H (6.47% to 2012-3-30), BAM.PR.I (6.77% to 2013-12-30) and BAM.PR.O (7.30% to 2013-6-30).
CM.PR.G PerpetualDiscount +1.3020% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.74% based on a bid of 20.23 and a limitMaturity.
CM.PR.I PerpetualDiscount +1.3264% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.76% based on a bid of 17.57 and a limitMaturity.
BNS.PR.K PerpetualDiscount +2.3891% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.77% based on a bid of 21.00 and a limitMaturity.
POW.PR.D PerpetualDiscount +2.6620% Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.19% based on a bid of 20.44 and a limitMaturity.
Volume Highlights
Issue Index Volume Notes
RY.PR.G PerpetualDiscount 54,635 RBC crossed 50,000 at 18.31. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.17% based on a bid of 18.30 and a limitMaturity.
MFC.PR.C PerpetualDiscount 51,700 RBC crossed 50,000 at 19.40. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 5.93% based on a bid of 19.28 and a limitMaturity.
RY.PR.W PerpetualDiscount 45,000 National crossed 34,400 at 19.75. Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.23% based on a bid of 19.75 and a limitMaturity.
SLF.PR.A PerpetualDiscount 35,300 Now with a pre-tax bid-YTW of 6.37% based on a bid of 18.94 and a limitMaturity.
BCE.PR.G FixFloat 35,300 RBC crossed 30,000 at 24.33.

There were eightteen other index-included $25-pv-equivalent issues trading over 10,000 shares today.

CRM Policy Group & Leverage Ratios

Thursday, August 7th, 2008

The Counterparty Risk Management Policy Group has released its August 6, 2008 Report. I have not read it in full, but it does have some things to say about the “leverage ratio” – known, roughly, in Canada as the Assets-to-Capital Multiple:

The Policy Group is strongly of the view that leverage ratios are a seriously flawed
measure of capital adequacy, except in highly unusual circumstances. The limitations that are inherent to leverage ratios were spelled out in the CRMPG I Report in 1999 and repeated in the CRMPG II Report in 2005.

As set out in detail in Appendix A of the CRMPG I Report, traditional measures of leverage, such as total on-balance sheet assets to equity, are misleading because they inadequately capture the relationship between the real risk of loss and the capital available to absorb it. A gross on-balance sheet leverage measure (1) does not take into account the potential variability in the value of off-balance sheet assets, (2) does not capture the risk dynamics of assets with embedded leverage, (3) does not give credit for hedging (including when matched book assets are perfectly hedged with offsetting liabilities), and (4) most importantly, fails to distinguish between assets with the same balance sheet value but widely differing risk. All balance sheet measures of leverage share a critical flaw in that a firm that appears to have relatively low leverage can nonetheless be taking substantial risks, while a firm that looks relatively highly leveraged may well be taking little risk. Viewed in isolation without greater understanding of the risk characteristics of portfolio assets, balance sheet measures of leverage can send false signals about a firm’s financial and risk condition. Appendix A to the CRMPG I Report explored these flaws and offered progressively more sophisticated measures of leverage to address them. In the end, CRMPG I concluded there is no single right measure of leverage. The challenge for financial institutions is to ensure that there is deep understanding and management of how asset liquidity and funding liquidity interact dynamically for a given portfolio of assets and sources of financing, including capital.

Notwithstanding the Policy Group’s view as to the shortcomings of leverage ratios, the Policy Group does recognize that (1) in some circumstances they can provide useful information and (2) in the aftermath of the credit market crisis they cannot be dismissed out of hand.

Recommendations
IV-21a. The Policy Group recommends that where the use of leverage ratios is compulsory, supervisors monitor such leverage ratios using the Basel II, Pillar II techniques and intervene regarding the adequacy of such leverage ratios only on a case-by-case basis.

IV-21b. The Policy Group recommends that efforts be directed at either (1) framing more meaningful leverage ratios where they exist or (2) phasing out their use and implementing alternative risk measures that more effectively fulfill their intended objectives.

The Policy Group is too ashamed of its 1999 Report to make it available on its website, but it’s available from the US Government