TD threw down the gauntlet and Flaherty’s picked it up.
The Ministry of Finance announced today that:
the Government will take steps to maintain the availability of longer-term credit in Canada by purchasing up to $25 billion in insured mortgage pools through the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC). This action will help Canadian financial institutions raise longer-term funds and make them available to consumers, homebuyers and businesses in Canada.
This relief to Canadian homebuyers and consumers comes at no fiscal cost to the taxpayer. Indeed, these securities will earn a rate of return for the Government that is well above the Government’s own cost of borrowing. Moreover, as insured mortgage pools in Canada already carry Government backing, there is no additional risk to the taxpayer.
This is, of course, the complete nonsense we have come to expect from government – any government, by the way, not just Harper’s. They will now have to go out and borrow $25-billion, which will – one should expect – push up the government’s cost of borrowing. We are, obviously, a long way from being in as bad a position as Iceland (or as bad as Canada, 1994), but this is the first step down that road.
There is no additional credit risk, to be sure, but that isn’t the only risk that applies to fixed income investment. Will they do the financing with matching term? Will they mark the positions to market?
I’m not saying this is a bad thing, mind, but I am saying that a little less public relations and a little more honest discussion of the issues would be greatly appreciated.
Also, this represents an easing of monetary conditions … remember the last currency debacle?
, the currency decline has more recently developed a momentum that, together with the upper pressure on medium- and longer-term interest rates, signals a diminishing of confidence in Canadian dollar investments. At the same time, the depreciation of the currency has resulted in a substantial easing of monetary conditions.
The Monetary Conditions Index is no longer fashionable, but the Bank acknowledges:
Together, interest rates and the exchange rate determine the monetary conditions in which the Canadian economy operates. Changes in the exchange rate affect spending and demand in the economy just as changes to interest rates can either increase or decrease the level of economic activity.
It will not have escaped notice by Assiduous Readers that:
Canada’s dollar weakened 14 percent since Sept. 26 as turmoil in global financial markets prompted investors to seek the relative safety of U.S. government debt.
That’s a lot of stimulus!
Anyway …