Malachite Aggressive Preferred Fund’s Net Asset Value per Unit as of the close Novembeer 30, 2023, was $8.5480.
Performance was affected by FTS.PR.M underperforming with a mere +6.41% gain [it outperformed last month], CU.PR.C at +8.71% and MIC.PR.A at +9.90% [repeating last month’s underperformance]. This was mitigated by good performance from PWF.PR.P (+15.91%), BN.PR.R (+13.87%) [after two months of underperformance] and TD.PF.C (+12.48%) [small holdings are not considered for individual mention here].
I feel it is only a matter of time before investors start paying attention to the fundamental risk of these instruments compared to their eye-popping interest-equivalent yields … and perhaps they have already and we have just seen the tide turn due to hopes that monetary policy will soon loosen, reinforced by good news for property insurers with respect to taxation of dividends from their preferred share holdings. But we’ve seen false starts before, so as always the best policy is to shut up and clip your coupons. The market continues to give considerable weight to Current Yield as a measure of valuation, ignoring or strongly deprecating the potential for large dividend increases on the next few years of resets.
FixedResets continue to yield more, in general, than PerpetualDiscounts; on November 30, I reported median YTWs of 8.21% and 6.94%, respectively, for these two indices; compare with mean Current Yields of 5.82% and 6.76%, respectively. RY.PR.J, to take a representative example, is calculated by HIMIPref™ as having a yield-to-worst of 8.31% at monthend (Current Yield of 4.24%); bid at 18.89, resetting 2025-5-24 at a spread of 274bp over GOC-5 (assumed to be constant at 3.82%) and currently paying 0.80 p.a. (3.20% annually). The next pay-date is 2024-2-24; it is trading cum-dividend.
If we plug the above data into the yield calculator for resets (which is discussed here and has recently been slightly modified), we arrive at a annualized (compounded semi-annually) yield of 8.21% for RY.PR.J . To take this 10bp (the difference between the spreadsheets and HIMIPref™) above the PerpetualDiscount median index yield of 6.94% (to account for the calculation methodological differences), which is to say 7.04%, requires the assumption that GOC-5 will be 2.79% forever, as opposed the ‘constant rate’ assumption of 3.82%. Well … pays yer money and takes yer chances, gents! Assiduous Readers with long memories will liken this to all the calculations of Break-even Rate Shock when the puzzle represented the same problem with a different sign! Note that even if the unfavourable scenario of GOC-5 = 2.79% is realized, this has only reduced the yield of RY.PR.J to that of the median adjusted PerpetualDiscount yield of 7.04%, which isn’t the worst outcome one might fear from one’s investments!
| Returns to November 30, 2023 |
| Period |
MAPF |
TXPR*
Total Return |
CPD – according to Blackrock |
| One Month |
+11.66% |
+9.47% |
N/A |
| Three Months |
+10.95% |
+7.93% |
N/A |
| One Year |
+8.63% |
+3.21% |
+2.66% |
| Two Years (annualized) |
-7.06% |
-6.62% |
N/A |
| Three Years (annualized) |
+6.95% |
+1.70% |
+1.17% |
| Four Years (annualized) |
+7.79% |
+2.81% |
N/A |
| Five Years (annualized) |
+4.12% |
+2.12% |
+1.54% |
| Six Years (annualized) |
+2.14% |
+0.64% |
N/A |
| Seven Years (annualized) |
+5.55% |
+2.91% |
N/A |
| Eight Years (annualized) |
+5.77% |
+3.25% |
N/A |
| Nine Years (annualized) |
+2.50% |
0.76% |
N/A |
| Ten Years (annualized) |
+3.28% |
+1.23% |
N/A |
| Eleven Years (annualized) |
+2.84% |
+1.10% |
|
| Twelve Years (annualized) |
+3.61% |
+1.49% |
|
| Thirteen Years (annualized) |
+3.38% |
+1.71% |
|
| Fourteen Years (annualized) |
+4.39% |
+2.27% |
|
| Fifteen Years (annualized) |
+8.71% |
+4.11% |
|
| Sixteen Years (annualized) |
+7.11% |
+2.28% |
|
| Seventeen Years (annualized) |
+6.36% |
|
|
| Eighteen Years (annualized) |
+6.37% |
|
|
| Nineteen Years (annualized) |
+6.38% |
|
|
| Twenty Years (annualized) |
+6.79% |
|
|
| Twenty-One Years (annualized) |
+7.81% |
|
|
| Twenty-Two Years (annualized) |
+7.37% |
|
|
| MAPF returns assume reinvestment of distributions, and are shown after expenses but before fees. |
| The BMO Capital Markets “50” Preferred Share Index is no longer being calculated. The final performance report incorporating this venerable index was published as of December, 2020. |
| “TXPR” is the S&P/TSX Preferred Share Index. It is calculated without accounting for fees, but does assume reinvestment of dividends. |
| CPD Returns are for the NAV and are after all fees and expenses. Reinvestment of dividends is assumed. |
| Figures for National Bank Preferred Equity Income Fund (formerly Omega Preferred Equity) (which are after all fees and expenses) for 1-, 3- and 12-months are +8.78%, +6.85% and +2.71%, respectively, according to Globe & Mail / Fundata after all fees & expenses. Three year performance is +2.70%; five year is +2.85%; ten year is +1.98%.
Figures from Morningstar are no longer conveniently available. |
| Manulife Preferred Income Class Adv has been terminated by Manulife. The performance of this fund was last reported here in March, 2018. |
| Figures for Horizons Active Preferred Share ETF (HPR) (which are after all fees and expenses) for 1-, 3- and 12-months are +9.04%, +8.11% & +5.56%, respectively. Three year performance is +3.70%, five-year is +2.72%, ten year is +1.96% |
| Figures for National Bank Preferred Equity Fund (formerly Altamira Preferred Equity Fund) are +9.38%, +9.09% and +6.60% for one-, three- and twelve months, respectively. Three year performance is +4.10%; five-year is +3.01%; ten-year is +3.08%
Acccording to the fund’s fact sheet as of June 30, 2016, the fund’s inception date was October 30, 2015. I do not know how they justify this nonsensical statement, but will assume that prior performance is being suppressed in some perfectly legal manner that somebody at National considers ethical.
The last time Altamira Preferred Equity Fund’s performance was reported here was April, 2014; performance under the National Bank banner was first reported here May, 2014. |
| The figures for the NAV of BMO S&P/TSX Laddered Preferred Share Index ETF (ZPR) is +4.48% for the past twelve months. Two year performance is -5.75%, three year is +3.89%, five year is +2.72%, ten year is +0.64% |
| Figures for Fiera Canadian Preferred Share Class Cg Series F, (formerly Natixis Canadian Preferred Share Class Series F) (formerly NexGen Canadian Preferred Share Tax Managed Fund) are no longer available as the Fund is now the property of Canoe Financial. The last reported performance for the merged fund was May 2020. |
| Figures for BMO Preferred Share Fund (advisor series) according to Morningstar are +9.28%, +7.94% and +2.65% for the past one-, three- and twelve-months, respectively. Three year performance is +0.02%; five-year is +0.07%; ten-year is -0.64%.
Note that figures from BMO are highly suspicious, so I have used figures from Morningstar |
| Figures for PowerShares Canadian Preferred Share Index Class, Series F (PPS) are no longer available since the fund has been terminated. Performance was last reported for the fund to month-end, March 2023 |
| Figures for the First Asset Preferred Share Investment Trust (PSF.UN) are no longer available since the fund has merged with First Asset Preferred Share ETF (FPR).
Performance for the fund was last reported here in September, 2016; the first report of unavailability was in October, 2016. |
| Figures for Lysander-Slater Preferred Share Dividend Fund (Class F) according to the company are -%, -% and -% for the past one, three and twelve months, respectively. Three year performance is +%, five-year is -%. |
| Figures for the Desjardins Canadian Preferred Share Fund A Class (A Class), as reported by the company are +8.69%, +7.06% and +2.61% for the past one, three and twelve months, respectively. Two year performance is -7.63%, three-year is +1.09%, five-year is +0.86% |
| Figures for the RBC Canadian Preferred Share ETF (RPF) are reported by Morningstar as +10.13%, +7.59% and +0.84% for the past one, three and twelve months, respectively. Three-year performance is ++2.41%, five-year is +1.62% |
| Figures for the Dynamic Active Preferred Shares ETF (DXP) are +9.0%, +7.9% and +5.5% for the past one, three and twelve months, respectively. Three-year performance is +6.1%; five-year is +4.3% |
| Figures for the Purpose Canadian Preferred Share Fund (Class F) are +8.93%, +9.48% and +5.83% for the past one, three and twelve months, respectively. Three-year performance is +6.13%; five-year is +3.24%; seven-year is +3.08%; ten-year is +4.67%. |
The five-year Canada yield declined, with the five-year Canada yield (“GOC-5”) falling from 4.16% at October month-end to 3.82% at November month-end.
The Seniority Spread (between long-term corporate bonds and interest-equivalent PerpetualDiscounts) was 375bp as of 2023-11-29 (chart end-date 2023-11-10) :
The situation with FixedResets is interesting, with the spread between GOC-5 and the interest-adjusted FixedReset (Discount) rate widening significantly from its 2021-11-10 low of 344bp a level of 705bp (as of 2023-11-29) … (chart end-date 2023-11-10):
…while at the same time the interest-equivalent spread between FixedReset (Discounts) and PerpetualDiscounts has narrowed to -159bp (as of 2023-11-29) from its 2021-7-28 level of +170bp (chart end-date 2023-11-10):
There is no significant correlation between the Issue Reset Spread and 1-month performance for discounted FixedResets for either the Pfd-2 or Pfd-3 Group issues.
Bigger news is that the normally moderate correlation between Issue Reset Spread and three-month performance has returned in this month’s check – at least for the Pfd-2 Group (20%)
This may be taken as at least a small sign that fundamentals such as credit quality, rather than interest-rate anticipation, are regaining importance in FixedReset pricing.
There was no significant correlation for either the Pfd-2 Group or the Pfd-3 Group for 1-Month performance against term-to-reset:
… and for three-month performance against term-to-reset, there was no correlation for the Pfd-2 Group but a small one (12%) for the Pfd-3 Group:
It should be noted that to some extent such a dependence (of performance on term-to-reset) can be justified as the nearer-term issues will receive the benefit of higher projected dividend rates sooner as a result of higher GOC-5 yields and therefore, perhaps, for longer. Equations for the relationship between correlation slope and change in GOC-5 were derived in the August 2022 PrefLetter. In the three months from August 31 to November 30, the GOC-5 rate declined from 4.08% to 3.82%, but this is a small move by recent standards. The smaller correlations may indicate a regime shift from recognition of a rise to expectation of declines in five-year yields, but at present the situation is chaotic.
I keep talking about ‘Sustainable Income’ and nowadays it’s far higher than the dividends that are currently being distributed. This is because Sustainable Income is the average yield-to-worst (YTW) of the portfolio when the YTW is calculated to perpetuity (or to redemption, of course, if the yield to redemption is lower), including resets at the current GOC-5 rate. The sharp increase in GOC-5 in the past year-odd has caused the difference between YTW and Current Yield to skyrocket, but one way or another I expect that these two values will become much closer – slowly at first, but quickening in about two years. We have to wait for the reset date of the MAPF portfolio securities before we see a change in actual cash receipts – and, of course, there is no guarantee whatsoever that the rate used for estimation purposes now will be used for the actual calculation in the future (chart prepared as of 2023-11-10).
I will note that the fund’s current holdings of FixedResets are now paying dividends based on their previous reset at an average GOC-5 rate of 1.27% (weighted by shares held). While nobody knows what the future might bring, I suggest that we won’t see GOC-5 return to that level again for a while!
| Calculation of MAPF Sustainable Income Per Unit |
| Month |
NAVPU |
Portfolio
Average
YTW |
Leverage
Divisor |
Securities
Average
YTW |
Capital
Gains
Multiplier |
Sustainable
Income
per
current
Unit |
| June, 2007 |
9.3114 |
5.16% |
1.03 |
5.01% |
1.3240 |
0.3524 |
| September |
9.1489 |
5.35% |
0.98 |
5.46% |
1.3240 |
0.3773 |
| December, 2007 |
9.0070 |
5.53% |
0.942 |
5.87% |
1.3240 |
0.3993 |
| March, 2008 |
8.8512 |
6.17% |
1.047 |
5.89% |
1.3240 |
0.3938 |
| June |
8.3419 |
6.034% |
0.952 |
6.338% |
1.3240 |
$0.3993 |
| September |
8.1886 |
7.108% |
0.969 |
7.335% |
1.3240 |
$0.4537 |
| December, 2008 |
8.0464 |
9.24% |
1.008 |
9.166% |
1.3240 |
$0.5571 |
| March 2009 |
$8.8317 |
8.60% |
0.995 |
8.802% |
1.3240 |
$0.5872 |
| June |
10.9846 |
7.05% |
0.999 |
7.057% |
1.3240 |
$0.5855 |
| September |
12.3462 |
6.03% |
0.998 |
6.042% |
1.3240 |
$0.5634 |
| December 2009 |
10.5662 |
5.74% |
0.981 |
5.851% |
1.1141 |
$0.5549 |
| March 2010 |
10.2497 |
6.03% |
0.992 |
6.079% |
1.1141 |
$0.5593 |
| June |
10.5770 |
5.96% |
0.996 |
5.984% |
1.1141 |
$0.5681 |
| September |
11.3901 |
5.43% |
0.980 |
5.540% |
1.1141 |
$0.5664 |
| December 2010 |
10.7659 |
5.37% |
0.993 |
5.408% |
1.0298 |
$0.5654 |
| March, 2011 |
11.0560 |
6.00% |
0.994 |
5.964% |
1.0298 |
$0.6403 |
| June |
11.1194 |
5.87% |
1.018 |
5.976% |
1.0298 |
$0.6453 |
| September |
10.2709 |
6.10%
Note |
1.001 |
6.106% |
1.0298 |
$0.6090 |
| December, 2011 |
10.0793 |
5.63%
Note |
1.031 |
5.805% |
1.0000 |
$0.5851 |
| March, 2012 |
10.3944 |
5.13%
Note |
0.996 |
5.109% |
1.0000 |
$0.5310 |
| June |
10.2151 |
5.32%
Note |
1.012 |
5.384% |
1.0000 |
$0.5500 |
| September |
10.6703 |
4.61%
Note |
0.997 |
4.624% |
1.0000 |
$0.4934 |
| December, 2012 |
10.8307 |
4.24% |
0.989 |
4.287% |
1.0000 |
$0.4643 |
| March, 2013 |
10.9033 |
3.87% |
0.996 |
3.886% |
1.0000 |
$0.4237 |
| June |
10.3261 |
4.81% |
0.998 |
4.80% |
1.0000 |
$0.4957 |
| September |
10.0296 |
5.62% |
0.996 |
5.643% |
1.0000 |
$0.5660 |
| December, 2013 |
9.8717 |
6.02% |
1.008 |
5.972% |
1.0000 |
$0.5895 |
| March, 2014 |
10.2233 |
5.55% |
0.998 |
5.561% |
1.0000 |
$0.5685 |
| June |
10.5877 |
5.09% |
0.998 |
5.100% |
1.0000 |
$0.5395 |
| September |
10.4601 |
5.28% |
0.997 |
5.296% |
1.0000 |
$0.5540 |
| December, 2014 |
10.5701 |
4.83% |
1.009 |
4.787% |
1.0000 |
$0.5060 |
| March, 2015 |
9.9573 |
4.99% |
1.001 |
4.985% |
1.0000 |
$0.4964 |
| June, 2015 |
9.4181 |
5.55% |
1.002 |
5.539% |
1.0000 |
$0.5217 |
| September |
7.8140 |
6.98% |
0.999 |
6.987% |
1.0000 |
$0.5460 |
| December, 2015 |
8.1379 |
6.85% |
0.997 |
6.871% |
1.0000 |
$0.5592 |
| March, 2016 |
7.4416 |
7.79% |
0.998 |
7.805% |
1.0000 |
$0.5808 |
| June |
7.6704 |
7.67% |
1.011 |
7.587% |
1.0000 |
$0.5819 |
| September |
8.0590 |
7.35% |
0.993 |
7.402% |
1.0000 |
$0.5965 |
| December, 2016 |
8.5844 |
7.24% |
0.990 |
7.313% |
1.0000 |
$0.6278 |
| March, 2017 |
9.3984 |
6.26% |
0.994 |
6.298% |
1.0000 |
$0.5919 |
| June |
9.5313 |
6.41% |
0.998 |
6.423% |
1.0000 |
$0.6122 |
| September |
9.7129 |
6.56% |
0.998 |
6.573% |
1.0000 |
$0.6384 |
| December, 2017 |
10.0566 |
6.06% |
1.004 |
6.036% |
1.0000 |
$0.6070 |
| March, 2018 |
10.2701 |
6.22% |
1.007 |
6.177% |
1.0000 |
$0.6344 |
| June |
10.2518 |
6.22% |
0.995 |
6.251% |
1.0000 |
$0.6408 |
| September |
10.2965 |
6.62% |
1.018 |
6.503% |
1.0000 |
$0.6696 |
| December, 2018 |
8.6875 |
7.16% |
0.997 |
7.182% |
1.0000 |
$0.6240 |
| March, 2019 |
8.4778 |
7.09% |
1.007 |
7.041% |
1.0000 |
$0.5969 |
| June |
8.0896 |
7.33% |
0.996 |
7.359% |
1.0000 |
$0.5953 |
| September |
7.7948 |
7.96% |
0.998 |
7.976% |
1.0000 |
$0.6217 |
| December, 2019 |
8.0900 |
6.03% |
0.995 |
6.060% |
1.0000 |
$0.4903 |
| March |
5.5596 |
7.04% |
1.006 |
6.998% |
1.0000 |
$0.3891 |
| June |
6.3568 |
6.10% |
0.9900 |
6.162% |
1.0000 |
$0.3917 |
| September |
7.2852 |
5.32% |
1.00 |
5.320% |
1.0000 |
$0.3876 |
| December, 2020 |
8.3947 |
4.46% |
0.999 |
4.464% |
1.0000 |
$0.3747 |
| March, 2021 |
9.6473 |
4.48% |
0.996 |
4.498% |
1.0000 |
$0.4339 |
| June |
10.3712 |
3.92% |
0.985 |
3.980% |
1.0000 |
$0.4127 |
| September |
10.7572 |
4.08% |
1.017 |
4.012% |
1.0000 |
$0.4316 |
| December, 2021 |
10.7432 |
4.31% |
0.999 |
4.314% |
1.0000 |
$0.4635 |
| March, 2022 |
10.5040 |
5.53% |
1.004 |
5.508% |
1.0000 |
$0.5786 |
| June |
9.3115 |
7.04% |
0.993 |
7.090% |
1.0000 |
$0.6672 |
| September |
8.4093 |
8.10% |
0.997 |
8.124% |
1.0000 |
$0.6916 |
| December, 2022 |
7.9921 |
8.47% |
0.996 |
8.504% |
1.0000 |
$0.6796 |
| March |
8.0788 |
7.90% |
0.997 |
7.924% |
1.0000 |
$0.6401 |
| June 30 |
8.0197 |
9.19% |
1.003 |
9.163% |
1.0000 |
$0.7348 |
| September 29 |
7.9922 |
9.86% |
0.997 |
9.890% |
1.0000 |
$0.7904 |
| November 30, 2023 |
8.5480 |
8.97% |
1.006 |
8.917% |
1.0000 |
$0.7622 |
NAVPU is shown after quarterly distributions of dividend income and annual distribution of capital gains.
Portfolio YTW includes cash (or margin borrowing), with an assumed interest rate of 0.00%
The Leverage Divisor indicates the level of cash in the account: if the portfolio is 1% in cash, the Leverage Divisor will be 0.99
Securities YTW divides “Portfolio YTW” by the “Leverage Divisor” to show the average YTW on the securities held; this assumes that the cash is invested in (or raised from) all securities held, in proportion to their holdings.
The Capital Gains Multiplier adjusts for the effects of Capital Gains Dividends. On 2009-12-31, there was a capital gains distribution of $1.989262 which is assumed for this purpose to have been reinvested at the final price of $10.5662. Thus, a holder of one unit pre-distribution would have held 1.1883 units post-distribution; the CG Multiplier reflects this to make the time-series comparable. Note that Dividend Distributions are not assumed to be reinvested.
Sustainable Income is the resultant estimate of the fund’s dividend income per current unit, before fees and expenses. Note that a “current unit” includes reinvestment of prior capital gains; a unitholder would have had the calculated sustainable income with only, say, 0.9 units in the past which, with reinvestment of capital gains, would become 1.0 current units. |
| DeemedRetractibles are comprised of all Straight Perpetuals (both PerpetualDiscount and PerpetualPremium) issued by BMO, BNS, CM, ELF, GWO, HSB, IAG, MFC, NA, RY, SLF and TD, which are not exchangable into common at the option of the company or the regulator (definition refined in May, 2011). These issues are analyzed as if their prospectuses included a requirement to redeem at par on or prior to 2022-1-31 (banks) or the Deemed Maturity date for insurers and insurance holding companies (see below)), in addition to the call schedule explicitly defined. See the Deemed Retractible Review: September 2016 for the rationale behind this analysis.
The same reasoning is also applied to FixedResets from these issuers, other than explicitly defined NVCC from banks.
In November, 2019, the assumption of DeemedRetraction for insurance issues was cancelled in the wake of the IAIS decision included in ICS 2.0. This resulted in a large drop in the yield calculated for these issues |
| The Deemed Maturity date for insurers was set at 2022-1-31 at the commencement of the process in February, 2011. It was extended to 2025-1-31 in April, 2013 and to 2030-1-31 in December, 2018. In November, 2019, the assumption of DeemedRetraction was cancelled in the wake of the IAIS decision included in ICS 2.0. |
| Yields for September, 2011, to January, 2012, were calculated by imposing a cap of 10% on the yields of YLO issues held, in order to avoid their extremely high calculated yields distorting the calculation and to reflect the uncertainty in the marketplace that these yields will be realized. From February to September 2012, yields on these issues have been set to zero. All YLO issues held were sold in October 2012. |
These calculations were performed assuming constant contemporary GOC-5 and 3-Month Bill rates, as follows:
| Canada Yields Assumed in Calculations |
| Month-end |
GOC-5 |
3-Month Bill |
| September, 2015 |
0.78% |
0.40% |
| December, 2015 |
0.71% |
0.46% |
| March, 2016 |
0.70% |
0.44% |
| June |
0.57% |
0.47% |
| September |
0.58% |
0.53% |
| December, 2016 |
1.16% |
0.47% |
| March, 2017 |
1.08% |
0.55% |
| June |
1.35% |
0.69% |
| September |
1.79% |
0.97% |
| December, 2017 |
1.83% |
1.00% |
| March, 2018 |
2.06% |
1.08% |
| June |
1.95% |
1.22% |
| September |
2.33% |
1.55% |
| December, 2018 |
1.88% |
1.65% |
| March, 2019 |
1.46% |
1.66% |
| June |
1.34% |
1.66% |
| September |
1.41% |
1.66% |
| December, 2019 |
1.68% |
1.68% |
| March, 2020 |
0.57% |
0.21% |
| June |
0.37% |
0.21% |
| September |
0.35% |
0.14% |
| December, 2020 |
0.42% |
0.08% |
| March, 2021 |
0.94% |
0.09% |
| June |
0.93% |
0.13% |
| September |
1.07% |
0.13% |
| December, 2021 |
1.31% |
0.16% |
| March, 2022 |
2.44% |
0.53% |
| June |
3.24% |
2.11% |
| September |
3.45% |
3.60% |
| December, 2022 |
3.37% |
4.35% |
| March, 2023 |
2.93% |
4.44% |
| June |
3.74% |
5.00% |
| September |
4.31% |
5.21% |
| November, 2023 |
3.82% |
5.14% |
PWF.PR.T To Be Extended
December 4th, 2023Power Financial Corporation has announced:
PWF.PR.T was issued as a FixedReset, 4.20%+237, that commenced trading 2013-12-11 after being announced 2013-12-2. PWF.PR.T reset at 4.215% effective 2019-1-31. I recommended against conversion and there was no conversion. It is tracked by HIMIPref™ and is assigned to the FixedReset Discount subindex.
Thanks to Assiduous Reader NK for bringing this to my attention!
Posted in Issue Comments | 1 Comment »